Good alternative to premium priced tyres for E46 BMW and similar Euro cars
I put these tyres on my BMW 316ti E46, bought secondhand with 17 BMW alloy wheels. Note on this car with this size, they are a staggered size 225/45/17 on front and 245/40/17 on rear - so tyre rotation is not possible front<>back as is the case with ...
I put these tyres on my BMW 316ti E46, bought secondhand with 17 BMW alloy wheels. Note on this car with this size, they are a staggered size 225/45/17 on front and 245/40/17 on rear - so tyre rotation is not possible front<>back as is the case with some cars. Tyres were nearly new (approx 20% worn).
First the good: reasonably quiet tyre on this car. Nice, responsive handling in wet and in dry. Reasonable wear, I got approx 45,000km out of them. What was really nice was that the fronts and rears wore out almost at the same rate (I had to replace the rears first, replaced with Pirelli - see separate review). Also a nice big rim protector/flange. Good feedback when doing a nice twisty road (think Black Spur, Tawonga Gap).
Next the not-so-good: Wet handling, particularly at the limit, should be better. I managed to completely lose it in the wet and actually spun the car, despite stability control. Admittedly (1) it was extremely heavy rain after extended dry period, so surface was really slippery and (2) I was deliberately trying to see what happens, this was done on asphalt but not in a traffic situation (carpark/industrial estate). When they do let go, they let go in a big way. So you do need to pay more attention in the wet, which you should always do. To be fair, I did not get to repeat this experiment on the replacement tyres so cannot give a direct like-for-like comparison.
Oh and they do tram-track. And the range of sizes is limited.
FInally the very bad: hard to find, very few tyre resellers have these, you really have to look for them. Or go Ebay.
There are other independent reviews out there [link removed] which also rate these quite highly.
Considering the price point (around $160 for the 225/45/17 and well under $200 for the 245/40/17, if you can get them), these are I think, exceptional value for a Japanese made performance tyre.
Yes you can buy Contis or Bridgestones or Pirellis but you ll be paying closer to $300 or more per tyre and they will not last as long. There are cheaper alternatives as well from the Koreans...
In conclusion - I definitely recommend these on both a performance and value dimension. Yes there are better tyres out there for 50% more outlay. But on a bang-for-buck, these are worth looking at, if you can find them.
Read more
Would buy this tyre again.
Similar opinion? Write a review!